Welcome to Goodfellas Pizzeria & Deli, a gem nestled in the heart of Farmingdale, NY. Located at 55 Central Ave # Q, this spot has rapidly made a name for itself as a delightful destination for food lovers. With a positive reception from both locals and visitors alike, it offers a diverse menu that promises something for everyone.

The owners and staff at Goodfellas have been repeatedly lauded for their warm hospitality and exceptional service, creating a welcoming atmosphere where you feel right at home. As customer Rory Schreiber puts it, “Owners are great and very helpful staff!! Food is excellent.” It's not just an eatery—it's a place where you can unwind, enjoy your meal, and feel part of a community.

Now, let's talk about the food. The menu boasts an impressive selection of both hot and cold dishes, catering to various palates. From delectable Philly cheesesteaks—highly praised by Shawn Byrd—to mouthwatering sandwiches as noted by William Cassidy, each dish reflects the care and quality that goes into its preparation. Joseph Garraffa mentions the great selection of food alongside the perfect pricing, making it an accessible option for anyone looking to satisfy their cravings without breaking the bank.

For those seeking variety, you’ll be pleased with the extensive choices available. The atmosphere, bolstered by friendly staff and ample seating, ensures that your dining experience is delightful, whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or sitting down to enjoy a leisurely meal. As Nos Delaolla aptly puts it, “Goodfellas is a vibe; food is great, customer service is top-notch, and it tastes awesome.”

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a returning customer, Goodfellas Pizzeria & Deli beckons with an open door and a promise of deliciousness. The next time you find yourself in Farmingdale, make a point to visit this charming pizzeria and deli; you're bound to leave with a satisfied palate and a happy heart.